|
Great post Frankie08. I will take it a little further if you don't mind.
I absolutely agree that it's too early to bank on anything, but personally when the Cubs made the deal with the A's I sighed a big sigh of relief. I'm sure I'm not alone in saying that when the Brewcrew acquired Sabathia it had me worried. The Brewers are a very good team and acquiring the reigning AL Cy Young award winner is huge, and it made our 3 1/2 game lead (at the time) seem a lot smaller. But Kudos to Jim Hendry. He took a lot of wind out of the Brewers' sail by making that deal immediately, rather than waiting until the trade deadline. Hendry responds by getting not 1 but 2 quality starting pitchers with a postseason resume and sent a message not just to Milwaukee, but the rest of baseball saying the Cubs are a serious team to contend with this year.
Ben Sheets and Rich Harden have both seen their share of time on the DL. The last full season either has pitched without a DL stint was in 2004. Sheets has made more starts in that time (63 to Harden's 33). Sheets and Sabathia stack up pretty evenly with Carlos Zambrano and Harden. I think the Cubs are a little deeper 3-5 with Ryan Dempster, Ted Lilly and Jason Marquis/Chad Gaudin. There are 2 key differences between the Cubs and Brewers rotations however that I think play big in the Cubs favor, especially since we are talking about 2 potential playoff teams.
First off, the Cubs rotation has 5 starters with postseason experience, the Brewers have 1 with CC Sabathia. Also, the Cubs have substantially more depth at pitching. If Sheets were to go down (based on his past a strong likelihood) his replacement is Jeff Suppan who has not pitched well at all this season. After Suppan, there isn't much of a viable option in Milwaukee. If Harden were to go on the DL, the Cubs have Marquis/Gaudin, Sean Marshall, or Jon Lieber waiting in the wings, all except Marshall have postseason experience.
|