Partners:   NCAA.com   CSTV.com   MaxPreps.com  
    
powered by Google  
CBSSports.com Pronger's eight-game ban more a benefit than punishment - NHL Sports News   Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 


Community | Help
Home    Fantasy    NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  Auto Racing  |  Tennis  |  Horses  |  SPiN  |  MMA & Boxing  |  More
Mobile  |  Shop
NHL Home | Scoreboard | Standings | Schedules | Stats | Teams | Players | Transactions | Injuries | Video | Fantasy News
 

Pronger's eight-game ban more a benefit than punishment

 

It's kind of ironic that in this instantaneous digital age, Anaheim Ducks captain Chris Pronger was able to initially avoid a suspension mainly because there was no good video footage of his despicable on-ice action this week.

Chris Pronger skates off with minimal discipline compared to less-talented Chris Simon. (Getty Images)  
Chris Pronger skates off with minimal discipline compared to less-talented Chris Simon. (Getty Images)  
That meant Pronger's act of stomping on the leg of Vancouver Canucks forward Ryan Kesler didn't make the mainstream network news and the NHL didn't have to be embarrassed by talking heads that never see a game lecturing about the ugly violence that is permeating its sport. And it gave the league's discipline-meister Colin Campbell the cover he needed to avoid taking one of the game's top players out of the lineup as the playoffs approach.

Enter the latter-day Zapruder factor, which in this case played out in the form of another tape of the incident that emerged and made its way to NHL offices, forcing Campbell to re-examine the situation. By the time he did, it was pretty obvious that even though this involved one of the league's top stars, it couldn't be swept under the rug.

At least not entirely, although Pronger's eight-game ban comes pretty close.

Pronger and Kesler collided on the end boards and the Canucks player went down, getting a leg wrapped around the Anaheim player's. Pronger looked like he was frantically trying to extricate himself at first to get back in the play, but once he did, he came down for good measure on the leg of the prone Vancouver forward before skating away.

The action was dangerous, not to mention eerily similar to what former New York Islander Chris Simon did to Pittsburgh's Jarkko Ruutu earlier this season. Ruutu fortunately wasn't hurt -- and neither was Kesler -- but Simon, who had been suspended seven times in the past, was banned for a league record 30 games.

"The deliberate act of kicking an opponent with an exposed skate blade, especially where the opponent is in a vulnerable position, is an always has been a repugnant and totally unacceptable act in the game of hockey," Campbell said in a statement when he handed down Simon's suspension.

Certainly not when the aggressor is only a marginal player, that is. Of course, the harshness of Simon's sentence was in large part the result of his history, something he couldn't help but mentioning when asked for his reaction after Pronger had apparently escaped the long arm of the law.

"It would be nice to have things treated fairly, at least," said Simon, who was traded to the Minnesota Wild shortly after his suspension ended. "I don't think in that instance it's fair at all."

Imagine what he's thinking now that Pronger has been given what amounts to a break to rest up for the playoffs. Apologists might argue that since Kesler avoided injury, there was no harm, no foul, but then again, we're talking about a perpetrator who many considered to be one of the dirtiest players in the league.

But unlike Simon, Pronger is a major talent, someone who is good enough to win a Norris and Hart Trophy and to be named to multiple All-Star teams. But he also has been reckless enough to lose it at some of the worst of times.

Pronger received the sixth and seventh suspensions of his career during the Ducks Stanley Cup run last spring, both for vicious blind side hits that injured opponents, but being that it was late in the playoffs, he was forced to sit down for just one game in each instance. There were more than one suggestion of favoritism at the time and it's fair to make a similar argument now.

Eight games is nearly 10 percent of the schedule, so it sounds harsh on the surface and make the NHL look like it is taking these kinds of acts seriously. But scratch a little deeper and you'll see it really doesn't mean much to Anaheim right now because it's too far out to overtake San Jose for the Pacific Division title and a top seed. The Ducks are destined to be fourth or fifth in the West, which is essentially the same to them because they are just as tough on the road as they are at home. And with Scott Niedermayer, Mathieu Schneider and Francois Beauchemin still patrolling the blue line, they can handle a few weeks that are largely inconsequential in their grand scheme of things.

Moreover, Anaheim has nine regular season games to go, so Pronger will even get a chance to get a quick tune-up in before the playoffs, which means this disciplinary action doesn't send much of a message to him. Just like the minimal suspensions failed to do last spring.

Back then the Ducks had several players step up in his absence and win both games he did not play. That's a credit to the team when it can rise that way when a star player is out, but it also tells Pronger, and other players of similar stature, that they can act with impunity and effectively get away with it.

Sitting Pronger through the end of the first playoff round at least might change his mind.

 
Talk Back
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Sep 8, 2006

March 16, 2008 1:12 pm

The NHLPA needs to ask that the NHL create a more standardized penalty system.  Which it wouldn't be that hard to do, come up with 15 or 20 common offenses:

  • Using the stick as a weapon - above or below the shoulders
  • Using the skate as a weapon
  • Blow to the head

Obviously there are more, but sit down and pool the minds of the ...(more)

Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Aug 23, 2006

March 15, 2008 11:00 pm
Wow. The NHL usually has subtle DOUBLE STANDARDS, but this is outright ATROCIOUS. Ive read on TSN.net that the difference between the 2 foot stomps was that Simon "seemed to snap", therefore he got 30 games. Thats a very convenient theory by the NHL. What about the fact that Simon stepped on the skate boot, which is very strong and could never be sliced clean through by a skate balde and ...(more)
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Oct 15, 2007

March 16, 2008 11:20 pm
Yeah , he is a pissed off dude. But if you look at the replay, it was not really as bad as they are making it out to be.  Granted Pronger is known for stuff like this , this was a minor penalty at least.
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 24, 2006

March 17, 2008 1:22 pm

Did you see how intentional it was when he stepped on the guys unprotected leg with his skate.  He could have sliced it wide open...

It was worse then what Chris Simon did because Simon stepped on the guys skate boot while the guy Pronger stepped on only had the sock covereing his leg.  Amazing he wasn't ...(more)

 
 
 
 
Related Links
 
Wes Goldstein
Recent Columns
 
Headlines
 
 
 
 
   

Fantasy Hockey at CBSSports.com