| Kris Ibezim C, Quinnipiac Braves |
| Martin Ides C, Davidson Wildcats |
| Mantas Ignatavicius G, High Point Panthers |
| Michal Ignerski F, Mississippi State Bulldogs |
| Jibrahn Ike G, Arkansas-Little Rock Trojans |
| Andy Ikeakor G, Tennessee Volunteers |
| Guy Ikpah G, Oklahoma State Cowboys |
| Dave Ilnicki F, Northeastern Huskies |
| Dommanic Ingerson G, Michigan Wolverines |
| Jack Ingram F, Tulsa Golden Hurricane |
| Tory Ingram G, Southern Jaguars |
| Justin Isham G, Southern Methodist Mustangs |
| Mat Ishbia G, Michigan State Spartans |
| Conrad Issak G, Idaho State Bengals |
| Ryan Iversen G, Delaware Blue Hens |
| Jeb Ivey G, Portland State Vikings |
| Royal Ivey G, Texas Longhorns |
| Terrell Ivory G, Davidson Wildcats |
| Marques Ivy F, South Alabama Jaguars |