The World Figure Skating Championships last week were plagued by so many
accidents and bizarre happenings that the event had almost the
character of a surrealistic dream instead of the biggest figure
skating competition of the year. It was a mad, mad, mad, mad,
Worlds.
The trouble actually started late last summer, when the International
Skating Union abruptly yanked the championships from their originally
planned venue of Brisbane, Australia, in a dispute over TV rights. The
Australian federation appealed the decision to the Court of Arbitration for
Sport, but the case has dragged on for months, with one postponement after
another and no decision yet announced.
In the meantime, the ISU made hasty arrangements with the French
federation to put on the competition in Nice, on a temporary ice sheet
set up with temporary seating in a convention hall.
Welcome to the weird world of sports. Some fans even wondered if all the
organization problems, accidents and other wild happenings at
this year's Worlds were a form of divine retribution for the ISU
taking the competition away from Australia. Or perhaps it was just
Murphy's law: If anything can go wrong, it will.
Skaters complained about the poor quality of the ice and lack of
privacy and quiet in the backstage areas. Fans complained about
uncomfortable hard plastic seats, poor sight lines, and inadequate
restrooms and food service at the competition venue.
From the perspective of U.S. skating fans, the surreal atmosphere of
these championships was even further emphasized by the pitiful TV
coverage being given to the event this year. Not only have the
ridiculous tape delays been giving the sense that the competition has
been held in a kind of time warp, but there's less broadcast time than
in previous years, and it's being filled with far too much fluff and
repetitive coverage.
For example, while ABC had a two-hour time slot for coverage of the
ladies' free skate, in that time they managed to show only six four-minute
programs. The remaining time was filled with such things as repeats of short
programs that had already been shown twice on ABC's cable partner ESPN, and
at least the fourth broadcast this season of a taped feature showing
Michelle Kwan at the beach.
Similarly, U.S. viewers only got to see only the men's free skates
three days after the event took place. The World Championships is by far the
most important competition of the year, but you'd never know it from the way
U.S. television has been treating it.
Some of the spectators who were present in the arena didn't seem to
know it, either. In the qualifying rounds, the stands were packed
with noisy schoolchildren who jeered rudely at skaters who fell.
Unfortunately, there were a lot of skaters who fell in the qualifying
rounds.
There were equally ugly displays by the crowd at the conclusion of the
pairs event, with the strongly nationalistic mob booing the
competitors who placed ahead of the French team and then disrupting
the medal ceremony by booing the competition officials. It didn't
help that the competition organizers also somehow misplaced the flags
of the medalists. At least they managed to play the right anthem.
Who would have guessed that the two-time pair champions Elena Berezhnaya
and Anton Sikharulidze would have been disqualified before the competition
even began because of a doping violation? The ISU issued a press release the
day of the starting draw stating that Berezhnaya had tested positive for a
banned stimulant at the European championships.
According to coach Tamara Moskvina, the culprit was a cough medication
Berezhnaya had been taking on the advice of a doctor, but it seems
incredible that nobody -- skater, coach, physician, or team leader --
thought to compare the ingredients to the list of banned substances. The ISU
Council has taken no formal action on the matter yet, but it seems all but
certain that Berezhnaya and Sikharulidze will be stripped of their European
title and receive the three-month suspension mandated by the rules for a
first offense of this nature.
If that weren't bizarre enough, French pair skater Stephane Bernadis
reported that he had been attacked in his hotel room by an unknown assailant
armed with a knife or razor -- and the press promptly began to question
whether he had made the whole story up as a publicity stunt. Move over,
Tonya Harding.
And there was drama on the ice as well. Ukrainian skaters Julia
Obertas and Dmitri Palamarchuk suffered a terrible fall on a lift at
the end of their program that left Palamarchuk sprawled senseless
after hitting his head and back hard on the ice. Onlookers watched in
horror as he was literally dragged off the ice before trained medical
personnel could check him out for possible head, neck, or back
injuries. The next team to skate, Canadians Kristy Sargeant and Kris
Wirtz, were so upset by the accident that they had to interrupt their
skate to ask the referee for additional time to compose themselves.
The pairs didn't have a monopoly on gory accidents, either. In one of the
dance practices, a collision with another couple left Bulgarian
dancer Albena Denkova with a deep gash in her leg that required
emergency surgery to repair sliced muscles. And Italian dancer Luciano Milo
was carried out of the arena on a stretcher after apparently breaking his
ankle during the actual competition.
Who would have guessed that French dancers Marina Anissina and Gwendal
Peizerat, who were more heavily favored to win their event than any other
competitors in Nice, would enter the final phase of their competition in
only second place following a stumble by Peizerat in the original dance? One
hates to think of what the partisan crowd would have done to the judges had
a similar mistake in the free dance cost the French team the overall title.
U.S. television commentator Terry Gannon probably breathed a sigh of
relief over Anissina and Peizerat's eventual victory, too -- prior to the
competition, he had vowed to swim back to America if they failed to win.
In the men's event, who would have guessed that Evgeny Plushenko, who had
looked all but invincible all through the season prior to Worlds would
completely crumble in his free skate and come away without any medal at all?
And this after all of his competitors had each made major mistakes in their
own programs, so that the door was wide open for him to claim the title.
Meanwhile, Elvis Stojko, who only a few years ago was virtually the only
skater landing quadruple jumps with any degree of consistency, came away
with a silver medal in spite of being the only one of the top five finishers
in Nice not to land a quad in any phase of the competition.
And who would have guessed that Michelle Kwan, after being criticized all
season long for allowing her technical skills to slip compared to her
competitors, would wind up presenting the most technically accomplished
performance in the ladies event, including the only clean triple/triple
combination in the competition? For Kwan, it was her best performance since
the 1998 U.S. Championships, and quite possibly the best performance of her
entire career.
It was a huge triumph -- not just a convincing victory against
competitors Irina Slutskaya and Maria Butyrskaya, but also against the
nay-sayers who have criticized Kwan for being over the hill at 19, for
pursuing an education and a life outside of the rink as well as skating, for
her unusual choice of dark and "difficult" music for her long program, and
for about a gazillion other imagined shortcomings.
If the weird happenings from earlier in the week seemed like the remnants
of a bad dream, Kwan's free skate provided a welcome antidote: there was no
doubt that this was the real thing, skating worthy of a world championship.